Skip to main content
Back to Chemistry

CHEMISTRY · ENERGY IN CHANGES

Hand Warmer Design Challenge

Foundations

Can you design a hand warmer that is warm enough, safe, and cheap?

You are an engineer. Your hand warmer must stay at 40 °C or warmer for 20 minutes, never get hotter than 55 °C, cost $3 or less, and weigh 50 g or less. Test packs, check the numbers, and improve your design.

  1. Choose what goes in the pack
  2. Activate it and watch
  3. Record and check the requirements
  4. Explain it, then take the test

Your teacher may tell you which lab to do. Each lab takes about 15 minutes.

What am I looking at?

  • Pack: the hand warmer you are testing, standing in a wire test stand. A breathable fabric pack lets air in; a sealed plastic pack does not. Packs that hold water are always sealed.
  • Insulation sleeve: a red cloth sleeve or a thicker blue foam sleeve around the pack.
  • Thermometer: its probe is taped to the pack. It shows the pack’s temperature in degrees Celsius (°C).
  • Timer: minutes since the pack was activated. A run shows 120 minutes in a few seconds.
  • Orange wavy arrows: energy moving. They point out of a pack that is warmer than the room and into a pack that is colder (the site’s color for thermal energy).
  • Zoomed-in model: a picture of the tiny particles inside the pack, drawn huge.
  • Graph: the pack’s temperature over time. The green band is the goal zone, 40 to 55 °C. The dotted line is the room, 20 °C.
  • Requirements check: each of the four requirements, with ✓ pass or ✗ not met.

Words to know

  • Energy: what can warm things up or make things move. A warm pack gives energy to your hand.
  • Exothermic: a change that gives off energy, so things around it get warmer. Endothermic: a change that takes in energy, so things around it get colder.
  • Oxygen: a gas in the air. Iron reacts with oxygen to make rust (iron oxide), a new substance.
  • Dissolve: a solid breaks apart into tiny pieces that mix into water.
  • Insulation: a layer that slows down energy leaving (or entering).
  • Requirement: something a design must do to count as a success. Natural resource: something we take from nature, like rock or oil. Synthetic: made by people, not found in nature.

About this model

Model: the temperatures, prices and masses are made-up teaching values for a small classroom pack. They are not a real product, a safety rating or a recipe.

  • The pack starts at room temperature, 20 °C. It gives off (or takes in) energy in a burst, and loses energy to the air. Insulation slows that loss.
  • Iron powder reacts with oxygen from the air and slowly rusts, giving off energy. Salt water helps the rusting go faster; the salt is not used up. A sealed plastic pouch keeps most of the oxygen out.
  • Calcium chloride gives off energy when it dissolves. Ammonium nitrate takes in energy when it dissolves, so its pack gets cold. Sodium acetate gives off energy when its dissolved particles form crystals. These three do not make a new substance.
  • Real air-activated hand warmers warm up in about 15 to 30 minutes and can stay warm for hours. One maker lists an average of about 57 °C and a maximum near 70 °C, which is why they should not touch bare skin for long. This model’s run is only 2 hours and its safety limit is 55 °C.
  • Real instant cold packs get to about 0 to 5 °C. In the model, the ammonium nitrate mix can’t get colder than about −15 °C, and no pack can pass 100 °C (its water would boil).
  • Real reusable sodium acetate packs are bigger (often 100 g or more) and stay near 54 °C while the crystals form. The small packs in this model do not get that hot.