Skip to main content
Back to Chemistry

MATTER · PHYSICAL AND CHEMICAL CHANGE

Physical vs Chemical Change Lab

File ▾

CHOOSE YOUR LEVEL

New substance, or the same stuff in a new form?

Both levels use the same bench of thirteen real changes, from melting ice to burning magnesium and a candle, with a balance, a temperature probe, a gas test, colour and solid checks, a “get it back?” test and a particle view.

About this model

What decides the kind of change. A change is chemical when new substances form and physical when the substances stay the same (OpenStax Chemistry 2e §1.3). Each of the thirteen bench processes is classified in the model, with its equation and the main evidence. Reversibility alone does not decide it: cut paper can’t be put back together but is still paper.

School convention: dissolving salt. When NaCl dissolves, the attractions between Na⁺ and Cl⁻ ions in the crystal are broken and each ion becomes surrounded by water molecules. Because no new substance forms and evaporating the water gives the salt back, schools classify dissolving salt as a physical change. This lab uses that convention and says so wherever salt appears.

The balance. In a closed container the measured mass never changes (conservation of mass). In an open container the model moves a fixed amount of matter across the boundary, in proportion to how far the process has gone: open boiling water loses 4.0 g of vapour; baking soda + vinegar loses 4.4 g of CO₂ (0.100 mol, from 8.40 g of baking soda); burning magnesium gains 1.6 g of oxygen (from 2.43 g of Mg, 2Mg + O₂ → 2MgO); rusting steel wool gains 1.2 g (from 2.79 g of Fe, 4Fe + 3O₂ → 2Fe₂O₃, an ideal dry oxide: real rust is hydrated); charring sugar loses 2.0 g of vapour and smoke, and a burning candle loses 1.0 g of wax that leaves as carbon dioxide and water vapour (both illustrative amounts). These are fixed teaching amounts, not a reaction-rate model, and they do not change with the starting mass.

The instruments. The temperature probe shows representative classroom values for about 100 g of material (for example, baking soda + vinegar cools by about 4 °C; damp steel wool warms by about 5 °C; dissolving salt cools by about 1 °C, ΔHsoln = +3.9 kJ/mol). They are not calibrated readings. A temperature change you cause (the hot plate) is never evidence. The gas, colour, solid and “get it back?” results are the observations described in OpenStax §1.3 and §4.2.

The particle view. Atoms are shown as shaded balls (colour plus the legend under the lens). In eleven processes every atom is kept: physical changes move the same particles into a new arrangement; chemical changes regroup the atoms into new substances (open containers let gas products leave and let oxygen in). The cooked egg and the charred sugar are schematic pictures, not atom-for-atom. The candle’s wax is drawn as short –CH₂–CH₂– pieces of its long molecules: some pieces only melt (same particles), others burn into CO₂ and H₂O.

Safety. This is a virtual bench. Burning magnesium gives off light bright enough to harm your eyes, so never stare at it; never heat a sealed container (the closed containers here have a balloon or a lid in the picture only to show a closed system).

What am I looking at?

How the lab works. Pick Explore or one lab at the top. Each lab has five tabs: Pre-lab, Bench, Data & graph, Claim · Evidence · Reasoning, and Test. On the Bench, the coach lists your steps; they tick themselves as you work. Press What do I do now? when you’re stuck.

The bench. A digital balance (green display) weighs the container and everything in it. An open container is a beaker, dish or pan; a closed one is a stoppered flask, a flask with a balloon to catch gas, a sealed bell jar or a lidded pan. The heated processes sit on a hot plate that is zeroed with the container. The temperature probe box shows its reading.

Evidence tests. After a run, press the buttons under the picture (or tap a card in the picture): Gas test (limewater for CO₂, glowing splint), Colour, Solid check (a precipitate is a new solid from two solutions) and Get it back? (cool it or evaporate the water). Each card turns green with a ✓ once you have tested it. In Labs 1 and 3, what you observed is listed beside the bench, above your evidence choices.

Particle view. Shows a magnified picture: the legend under the lens names every particle. Physical: the same particles move to a new arrangement. Chemical: atoms regroup into new substances; a gold ring marks each regrouping.

The graph. Balance reading against percent completed: closed (solid line, circles) and open (dashed line, hollow diamonds). The big marker is where you are now.

Controls. The bar under the picture: ▶ runs the process; Step 25 % › moves 25 % and pauses; the speed buttons slow it to 0.1× or speed it to 3×; ↺ Reset starts the bench again (your data, answers and C·E·R stay). The speaker button turns on sound effects (off at first; everything they signal also shows on screen), and Model limits lists what this model simplifies. Keys: Space play / pause · → step · R reset · Z / X zoom · H this help. Tap the container to switch the particle view on or off; drag to move a zoomed-in scene.